In today’s world of online activism, heaps of articles have been written about switching from non-recyclable plastics to paper alternatives, especially when talking about straws or food and beverage items. On the surface, this seems like a great switch. However, when you look a little more closely, switching to paper is more of a deflection than a solution.
According to the Idaho Forest Products, there are several steps to making paper for all sorts of paper products.
- Trees are cut down and cut into lumber.
- The excess of this process is ground into wood chips.
- The wood chips are then processed into pulp.
- The pulp is put through a paper-making machine where it’s thinned, pressed, and dried.
- The paper can then be cut for various products.
For 1 metric ton of paper, this process requires 17 trees, 6,604 gallons of water (25 cubic meters), 10,061 kWh of energy, and 680 gallons of oil.
For comparison sake, plastic is made of compounds derived from non-renewable resources such as coal and oil, and 22 gallons of water are used to make a pound of plastic (22 gallons x 2204 pounds in a metric ton= 48,488 gallons). Additionally, many of the plastic products we use that can be recycled, usually aren’t. In fact, only about 9% of plastics ever made have been recycled.
But paper can be recycled pretty easily, right? Yes! But only some paper can be recycled.
“Each time paper is recycled, the cellulose fibers get shorter, until eventually the paper won’t hold together. That’s why most “recycled” papers contain some new paper fibers mixed in with the old.” 1
However, paper often can’t be recycled if its been soiled or wet, which includes paper plates, towels, pizza boxes, and straws.
While paper may not use as many resources as plastic, production of those products still require raw materials which can quickly become overwhelming. If you’re buying paper products for food and beverage, it can’t be recycled at all which defeats the purpose of a switch. After all, waste in a landfill is still waste in a landfill, no matter the material.
This leads to the question: I don’t want to use plastic but paper isn’t a good option either, what do I do?
The most obvious solution is to just use what you already have. Take your own coffee mug to the office, use a real plate and wash it when you’re done, or you can even wrap up your own silverware in a napkin and carry it with you in your bag or purse for when you’re out and about. And if you don’t need a straw, simply don’t use one (or use the one from the reusable cup I know you have sitting in your cabinet). If you do have to buy something, always look for it secondhand first. This eliminates demand for new products using raw materials + shipping and handling.
If you’re reading this article and are saying to yourself, “I have <insert issue here> I need a plastic disposable straw to drink! What do I do?” You do your best. I know many chronically ill people who feel guilty because they require non-recyclable medical supplies, medications with a lot of packaging, or even plastic straws to live their every day life. This is perfectly okay! You have to do what you have to do to survive and thrive. Even if it’s just recycling the junk mail you get, doing something is better than doing nothing.
The solution for many of the waste problems we have are only going to be solved by changing the way we think about waste. Instead of asking what you can buy to replace your current product, ask yourself what you can do without.
Click to read more about living eco-friendly!